Shop The Ranges At Left Field NYC

How to get the perfect fit in your Red Wing Boots

Earlier this year, we asked our readers to think of everything they ever wanted to know about Red Wing Shoes.We took your questions to the guys from Red Wing Shoes Berlin, Hamburg, and Munich and now we have the answers.

Instead of a regular Q&A, we’ve divided the answers to your questions into three parts, together comprising the ultimate Red Wing buyer’s and owner’s guide.

In Part 1, which is this article, we will give you the definitive guide on how to size and fit your Red Wing Shoes; how they should feel when you first try them on and what you should look for when purchasing your first pair of Red Wings.

In Part 2 we will talk about the best way to break in your new boot. We will also look at the materials and manufacture of a pair of Red Wings as well as the ethical and sustainable issues associated with such a high quality product.

In Part 3 we will explore the maintenance and care of your Red Wing Shoes as well as your options when it comes time to resole your boots.

So, let’s get you into a pair of quality boots!

Red Wing Denimhunters

The Importance of Change

I’ve had my Red Wing 877s for about three years now, and to be honest they are hardly off my feet. During a chat with Kay Knipschild, owner of the Red Wing stores in Berlin, Hamburg and Munich, he mentioned the importance of letting your boots dry for a short time in-between wears.

WELL WORTH A READ >  Finding Your Perfect Raw Selvedge Denim Jeans: What Denim Weight is Right for You?

So I headed along to Red Wing Shoes Berlin in search of another pair.

Red Wing Denimhunters

Starting From Scratch

I had expected to simply go in, ask for the style I wanted, in the same size I had in my 877s, and that would be it.However, each pair of Red Wings has its own subtleties and quirks.Even if you were buying the same boot, the guys will treat you like you were buying your first pair.

Your Specific Measurements

First off you get your feet measured up. This is a pretty important step.You may think you know your true size but with a pair of Red Wings it is quite likely you will need to size down.

Each store has a Red Wing specific tool. It not only measures the length but also the width of your foot. Turns out I am an exact US size nine on the right, slightly smaller on the left and I have slightly narrow feet. All important information.

A to Double E

No, get your minds out the gutter, this is about shoe width. Some Red Wing models come in the full range of sizes, as Kay Knipschild explains:

“A is really thin, like a stick and it goes all the way to double E which is like a square. However, you can serve 80-90% of the population with a D width.”

Red Wing Denimhunters

The Fitting

When you get to your second or maybe even third pair of Red Wings it is easy to find your right fit. It should be noted however, if you are coming from a pair of sneakers it is a big leap. There are a few points you need to watch out for.Toes: The first thing you need to ensure is that your toes have some air, some freedom of movement. If they are squeezed together or pushed right up against the front of the shoe it is a no go.

WELL WORTH A READ >  Everything You Ever Wanted To Know About Red Wing

Feel: The boots should sit tight on your foot from the sides, tighter than you are normally used to if you are coming from fashion boots or trainers. Try to get the boot the smallest size while maintaining movement around the toes.

Proportions: You need to test to see if the boot will bend in the right place. If you have a wide foot and you need to size up accordingly your toes may sit too far back, which will create a lot of discomfort. You will see that the boot bends in the wrong place.

In the end I sized down half a size from the 877’s. It is a very different boot and I felt that I had too much movement in the heel. It is these specifics that make all the difference.


When he was measuring up my feet, Mick noticed that I was wearing totally inappropriate socks. A good sock is essential to getting the perfect fit from your Red Wings. Business socks are not suitable, they are too thin and flimsy. The minimal you should go with is a tennis sock.

They have a box of socks you can borrow when buying your boots but I would encourage you to spring for a pair of your very own.

Learn about how to buy Red Wings online on page two.

1 2
  • Arief Kurniawan Pattawari

    Hi, Matt

    Thank you for this article. I find it very helpful. I’m about to get my very first Red Wing 1907. So i went to the local store today and i am torn between 2 sizes, 10 and 11.

    On 11, there’s till room in the front so then my toes can make movement freely. On the other hand, it doesnt sit tight from the sides. As i tried to walk, i can feel my heel was moving.

    So i tried size 10. It fits perfectly on my feet. It feels tight from the sides, and heels, and toes. But toes do not have any room to move. It just fit. I find this size to be more confortable as i walk.

    Now i’m torn between those two sizes, whether to give my toes some air as you said (size 11), or get the all fit from sides, heels, and toes (size 10).

    Please advise as i will be purchasing one of them anytine soon.

    Really appreciate it.

  • Denimhunters

    Hi Arief,
    Thomas here. I’m assuming the store didn’t have a size 10.5? Personally, I would probably got for the smaller size.

  • Arief Kurniawan Pattawari

    Hi Thomas,

    Thanks for your promot response. Yes, they do not have size 10.5. I think i’m gonna wait until they restock 10.5 for comparison.

  • purlogik

    I bought a pair of Irish Setter boots last year (made by Red Wing?) and I found them really hard to size. They sized me at the shop as a 9.5, which is what I normally wear in a dress shoe. When new, the boots felt really tight, but I was expecting them to break in a little. After wearing them only a few times, they started feeling too big and I wear thick wool socks with them. Love the boots but I want them to fit, and this is kind of frustrating IMO. I feel like the only way to know my size for sure is to buy a size 9 and wear them for a year. The point of all that is this: does Red Wing sizing stay consistent over the years?

No more articles